Jeff Ostrowski, Bankrate.com
The traditional wisdom about private mortgage insurance (PMI) was that borrowers should try to avoid it. PMI is a traditional mortgage borrower requirement that beat less than 20% on a home, and another cost to narrow down first-time home buyers.
However, in recent years, private mortgage insurance companies have reduced their fees.
“I’m a big fan of mortgage insurance. It’s kind of a dirty word. When you talk to customers, they don’t tend to like it,” says Emmanuel Santa Donato, Senior Vice President of Tomo Mortgage. says. “But looking at the actual costs of mortgage insurance compared to being able to reduce 3% or 5% is a huge advantage. That money can be used elsewhere.”
What is Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI)?
PMI is a requirement for traditional mortgage borrowers who pay a down payment of less than 20% at home. The borrower pays for the report, but the PMI protects the lender, not the borrower. If the borrower stops defaulting, or payment, the loan, lender will receive payments from the PMI carrier.
PMI is a temporary cost. By law, lenders must cancel when the mortgage balance drops to 78% of the original purchase value of the home, or if it is in the middle of the loan term, whichever comes first.
However, even before this scheduled date, once you have repaid your balance to 80% of the original value of your home, your lender can request that you remove the PMI. In that case, you will need to pay for the valuation or broker’s price opinion to establish value.
For years, home buyers have been extremely opposed to paying PMI, jumping over hoops, including getting piggyback loans. With this type of loan, the buyer will pay a 10% down payment and then get a second mortgage to the other 10%. loan.
Is PMI expensive now?
Today, the average cost of private mortgage insurance is around 0.4% of the amount of the loan. For example, if you were paying a PMI on a $400,000 loan, your premium would be $1,600 a year, or about $133 a month.
Recently in 2019, borrowers could expect to spend more than that: about 0.5%. In the same scenario, it would be $2,000 a year or $167 a month.
Of course, the average is average. The PMI rate is based on a variety of factors, including credit scores, debt-to-income ratios, and local housing market dynamics. Instead of lowering 10% or 15%, if you lower 3%, you pay a higher premium. PMI is designed to protect lenders from default risks, with the higher the risk that mortgage insurers perceive, the higher the premium.
Recent research by the Urban Research Institute shows how much the costs of PMI differ. For traditional borrowers who beat 3% and have a credit score of less than 680, PMI costs more than 1% of the loan amount each year. However, less than 0.5% of borrowers have a down payment of 3% and a credit score of 760 or higher.
Why is the PMI rate falling?
The private mortgage insurance industry consists of half a dozen careers. This is a list that includes mortgage guarantee insurance, Radian Group, national mortgage insurance, and arch mortgage insurance. Over the past decade, these companies have adjusted their pricing models to more accurately reflect the risks posed by individual borrowers.
“A decade ago, there were very standard rate cards each of the PMI lenders gave to the lenders,” says Chris Grimes, senior director of Fitch Ratings. “Now there are very dynamic processes, if not hundreds, if not thousands of factors.”
A new approach allows PMI carriers to closely match each borrower’s risk profile to the premium.
“Pricing is more granular than before, and that’s how you can get a more accurate premium,” said Carl Tyree, Chief Sales Officer at Arch Mortgage Insurance.
Should I pay the PMI?
With home prices at record highs, supporting a 20% down payment is not an option for many home buyers, especially first time buyers.
However, ask yourself if you have enough financial flexibility to choose a 20% down payment and a lower one. “What else can you do with money? Do you want to take that extra fairness and invest it?” Santa Donato says.
Below are two hypotheses facing $500,000 home buyers:
– Create a 20% down payment of $100,000. Assuming your 30-year mortgage is 7%, your monthly loan payment is $2,661.
– Create a 10% down payment of $50,000. The loan amounts to up to $450,000, so monthly payments will rise to $2,994. Assuming PMI Premium is 0.35%, you’ll end up paying an additional $131 in monthly PMI costs, resulting in a total payment of $3,125.
There is no correct or wrong answer. Adding $50,000 to a bank or investment costs $464 per month. This is the difference in mortgage payments between the first and second scenarios. From there, it’s a personal decision about how much fluidity you value.
Conclusion
PMI still charges additional costs, but in recent years the fees have been reduced sufficiently as borrowers no longer have to reflexively avoid it.
©2025 Bankrate.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
