A farm bill moving through Florida’s Republican-controlled Legislature would impose new restrictions on free speech.
Section 47 is found in Senate Bill 209 and House Bill 433. It’s a provision that critics say would impede free speech to criticize or provide opposing analysis on certain agricultural issues that could harm Florida’s drinking water system.
“Big Sugar’s muzzle clause threatens free speech, public accountability, and our ability to speak openly about practices that impact Florida’s water quality,” said Chris Whitman of Captains for Clean Water (CFCW).
At one of the hearings, a group affiliated with CFCW included small business owners, members of the tourism community, fishing guides, and conservation groups.
Despite the opposition that filled the room, House Republicans ignored free speech concerns and moved forward with the bill.

Groups associated with President Trump, such as MAHA (Make America Heathy Again), are currently joining CFCW in opposing Republican support for the farm bill.
MAHA and CFCW have revealed the content of the bill, which targets groups that criticize the bill’s attack on free speech.
The scope will be expanded to include not only non-perishable foods such as sugarcane, but also fresh foods such as fruits and vegetables.

Expand to include agricultural practices such as the use of fertilizers, herbicides, and pesticides.
Add unilateral legal fees to dominant producers.
“We are telling fishing guides, small business owners, parents, journalists, and activists that speaking out, even if their concerns are legitimate, can have devastating economic consequences,” said CFCW’s Chris Whitman.
MAHA members told The Florida Daily that cabinet members within the Trump administration are closely monitoring the bill and the concerns it poses to people’s First Amendment rights.
All Republicans on the House committee voted unanimously to advance the bill, despite opposition from supporters of the MAGA movement and supporters of Florida Governor Ron DeSantis.
Where will the proposed legislation go next?
A hearing will be held in the Senate Rules Committee on Tuesday, February 10th at 9am.

